North East Derbyshire Statement of Community Involvement 2023

Ended on the 29 March 2023
For instructions on how to use the system and make comments, please see our help guide.

Appendix E - What is a Material Consideration?

When a decision is made on a planning application, only certain issues can be taken into account; these are often referred to as 'material considerations'.

Material considerations can include (but are not limited to):

  • Local, strategic and national planning policies, most notablythe policies of the Development Plan
  • Emerging new plans and policies
  • Previous appeal decisions
  • Principles of Case Law established through the Courts
  • Amenity issues
  • Highway issues: traffic generation, vehicular access, highway safety
  • Noise or disturbanceresulting from a use
  • Smells and fumes
  • Capacity of utilities infrastructure,e.g. drainage or water systems
  • Impacts on social infrastructure, e.g. schools and health facilities
  • Storage and handling of hazardous materials
  • Impacts from contaminated land
  • Impact on nature conservation interests & biodiversity
  • Effect on listed buildings and conservation areas
  • Design, layout and appearance.
  • Landscaping and means of enclosure

The weight attached to material considerations in reaching a decision is a matter of judgement for the decision-taker. However, the decision-taker is required to demonstrate that in reaching that decision that they have considered all relevant matters.

Greater weight is attached to issues supported by evidence. If a problem can be dealt with by a condition in a planning permission the Local Planning Authority is required do this instead of refusing an application.

What is not a Material Consideration?

The following issues cannot be given weight in making decisions on planning applications. (This list is not exhaustive.)

  • Matters controlled under Building Regulations or other regulatory systems.
  • Private issues between neighbours, such as land/boundary disputes, damage to property, covenant, private rights of access, etc.
  • Opposition to the principle of development when this has already been determined by an outline planning permission.
  • Applicant's personal circumstances (unless exceptionally and clearly relevant e.g. provision of a facility essential for the support of someone with special needs)
  • Opposition to business competition
  • Loss of property value
  • Loss of view
For instructions on how to use the system and make comments, please see our help guide.
back to top back to top